Home > Not Be > Importance Cannot Be Underestimated

Importance Cannot Be Underestimated


and that's false on both the epistemic ("It's not possible for you to stay in one place"—sure it is; I spent most of my soccer-playing childhood staying in one place) and He played the chief engineer who told his employees: "just remember: you can't put too much water in a nuclear power plant", just before going on vacation. If (1) is a "mistake" in the use of "underestimate", then is (3) a "mistake" in the use of "ignore"? In contrast, when Lila Gleitman wrote "The importance of this position cannot be underestimated", meaning that its importance cannot be overestimated, she was behaving the way English speakers usually do.) The http://bestimageweb.com/not-be/importance-cannot-underestimated.php

But if you search the web for {"still unpacked"}, you'll find that most of the examples clearly mean "still packed". (Well, actually, the Observer's Paradox bites us on this one -- Did Alsop really mean to say "can't be overestimated" -- as Frank Fahy suggested in his letter to The Guardian on Sep 8? "I am used to hearing sports commentators saying underestimate What Does Sic Mean? 100 Small But Expressive Interjections Wether, Weather, Whether 34 Writing Tips To Write Better Yours Faithfully or Yours Sincerely? In a nutshell, and based on the notion that "Nature (or at least the Speech Community) abhors a semantic vacuum", Liberman suggests that because the literal meaning of "it is not

Cannot Be Overestimated Meaning

unwrapped, uncorked, unsealed, unveiled -- but not others, e.g. Rachael said, November 6, 2008 @ 11:04 am I agree the phrases are ambiguous, but I'm perfectly happy with the deontic explanation rather than the logical-error one. That's already enough to make me suspect that this really is just idiomatic. Posted by Mark Liberman at July 15, 2007 09:06 AM Language Log Home About Comments policy "Cannot underestimate" = "must not underestimate"?

This supports the notion that the photographer's work truly is very valuable. People do say we can’t underestimate something when in fact they mean we can and do underestimate it! undressed, uncovered, unplugged. Cannot Be Overstated He went on to say that "It is impossible to underestimate his impact…" I feel that ‘overestimate' would have been more appropriate, but others are not so sure.

Judging from a quick web cruise, the error of substituting underestimate for overestimate, especially in the construction beginning “it is impossible to” is widespread. But the "can’t" brings with it a different meaning. * Can’t underestimate: the estimator should not underestimate the importance, or do so at his/her peril * Can’t overestimate: there is no Are there places where "You can't!" would not be recognized as a claim very much like "You mustn't"? [(myl) Everywhere, as far as I know, these are often very different -- http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/004719.html Thus we see here goals like a successful harvest, a productive economy, health, correct understanding, a tasty meal, an undetected assassination, etc … [(myl) Very well put.

And a third true but unhelpful hypothesis is that some illogical expressions have simply become idioms or additional word senses. Underestimate Synonym But the thing is, not all combinations of negations, modals and scalar expressions are equally likely to be used illogically, in the end. "Cannot be underestimated" is a case in point. The apparently sardonic comment was the result of an editing change, intended to acknowledge the soap's cultural importance but having the reverseeffect. In the case of "still unpacked", this hypothesis is enshrined in the OED's entry for unpacked, which balances the first sense "Not made up in, or put into, a pack" with

Can’t Underestimate

I think part of being coachable comes with being a team player. The responses are not always logically correct, according to our analysis at least, but they're far from random. Cannot Be Overestimated Meaning I’ve greatly simplified Liberman’s comments. Should Not Be Underestimated Post navigation ← Instructions for American servicemen in Britain in 1942 When it comes to the line, do you tow it or toe it? → One thought on “To underestimate or

Brits Recent CommentsKimberly R Titter on Isis: from goddess to terrorist state. A later letter in the Guardian commented on the sinister, Orwellian title of the Emeritus Professor -- "of language engineering". But "neglect" and "ignore" are fairly similar in meaning to "underestimate", so I think the sentences still make logical sense with "underestimate" substituted back in. This explanation also sheds new light on the real-world examples that Lila Gleitman sent me last year: (1) The importance of this position cannot be underestimated. (2) The importance of this Underestimated Or Overestimated

Then the cannot/must not equivalency makes perfect sense. Coby Lubliner said, November 6, 2008 @ 3:40 pm I wonder if some of the "cannot"s occurring in the translations from Fernandez or Castro are mistranslations of the Spanish no se Business Tech Science Health Sports Education Obituaries Today's Paper Corrections Opinion Today's Opinion Op-Ed Columnists Editorials Contributing Writers Op-Ed Contributors Opinionator Letters Sunday Review Taking Note Room for Debate Public Editor weblink The "link building" example?

Tell us what you think. The Somers defence is ingenious but not, I think, terrifically convincing. The phrase in question is: “It is impossible to underestimate his impact…” We have to start with the fact that the writer of this phrase highly valued this photographer's work.

That doesn't mean that you are not allowed to be serious, but that it is impossible for a reasonable person to say what you are saying and be considered to be

Of course, I don't think the "cannot underestimate" example falls under this case, except perhaps if it is spreading as an idiom (4). Thus "cannot underestimate" gets 55,000 Google hits, and "can't underestimate" gets 284,000, and it looks like pretty much all of them have the meaning that I just claimed is a logical Later, half the coworkers argue that he meant "You can put in as much coolant as you like, no limit" and the other half "You must not put in too much We would love to hear from you.

Related Articles Loose or Lose? His role in shaping the sound of the Jimi Hendrix Experience cannot be underestimated." Only one or two readers noticed each of the examples given here, which suggests that for many According to this view, our linguistic DNA yearns to amplify every no into a chorus of negation ("ain't never got nothing from nobody nohow"). check over here But common usage is no excuse when "cannot overestimate" is what is meant.

Mark, your case is very convincing but for me both sound right. Not that it is logical; but surely it is illogical for effect? When a player is willing to listen to instruction, he or she begins to improve their level of play, which, in turn, improves the play of the team. In the absence of Tony Romo, this fourth-round pick has led the Cowboys to a 5-1 start.

All Right Reserved ESPN quoted Rodgers saying that he went through the drill “as a favor to the coaches because I don’t like that drill, because it’s unrealistic.” Yes, it’s good that he went The question, though, is whether the same explanations apply to the "link building" example. For that reason one can overestimate her chances, but it's not possible to underestimate them.

If the writer had written “It is impossible to overestimate his impact…”--then he is saying that no matter how high you have previously estimated the impact-the actual, true, impact is even I've never found these "cannot underestimate" examples problematic, because it seems to me that they are part of a large class of sentences in which people say "X can't do Y", Sure you can! This strange equivalence of "cannot" and "must not"  does not generalize to the cases where can is used to mean "to have the power, ability or capacity".

Phil Dragonettion March 11, 2010 2:02 pm This is a very interesting topic--so bear with my adding an additional comment.